Home National Bengal nawab who died combating British turns tormentor of Hindus in BJP’s ballot narrative

Bengal nawab who died combating British turns tormentor of Hindus in BJP’s ballot narrative

Bengal nawab who died combating British turns tormentor of Hindus in BJP’s ballot narrative


Of the 42 Lok Sabha seats in West Bengal, Nadia district’s Krishnanagar is witnessing a novel marketing campaign during which the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) is projecting Siraj-ud-Daulah, Bengal’s final impartial Nawab, as corrupt and a tormentor of Hindus.

New Delhi, Mar 27 (ANI): Prime Minister Narendra Modi was reportedly in a telephonic conversation with Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) candidate from Krishanagar Lok Sabha candidate Amrita Roy, on Wednesday. (ANI Photo)(ANI) PREMIUM
New Delhi, Mar 27 (ANI): Prime Minister Narendra Modi was reportedly in a telephonic dialog with Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) candidate from Krishanagar Lok Sabha candidate Amrita Roy, on Wednesday. (ANI Photo)(ANI)

The saffron camp’s narrative challenges nineteenth and Twentieth-century historians whose analysis proves that conspirators, of whom a number of have been Hindus, helped the East India Company defeat the 24-year-old Nawab within the Battle of Plassey in 1757. Indeed, it was this battle that marked the start of the British empire that lasted until Independence.

BJP has fielded Amrita Roy, a member of the erstwhile royal household of Krishnanagar that helped the British defeat Siraj-ud-Daulah. BJP has been referring to her as Rajmata (queen mom) in its marketing campaign.

The battle was fought at Nadia district’s Palashi. Siraj-ud-Daulah, who reigned for round 15 months, was assassinated in jail days later on the instruction of Mir Jafar, his normal and the chief of the conspirators whom the British positioned on the throne as their tax gathering puppet, say historical past books college and faculty college students have been studying for greater than a century.

In Bengal, many nonetheless consult with a treacherous particular person as Mir Jafar, a synonym for Brutus who conspired to assassinate the Roman emperor Julius Caesar.

The BJP’s narrative has triggered sturdy reactions in Bengal, particularly amongst academicians, since March 27 when the saffron camp broadly circulated the audio file of a telephonic dialog Prime Minister Narendra Modi had with Amrita Roy.

Roy, who joined the BJP on March 20 with no expertise in politics, has been pitted towards TMC’s Mahua Moitra who received the Krishnanagar seat in 2019 however was expelled from the Lok Sabha in December final 12 months within the bribe-for-query case that federal businesses are probing.

While speaking to Modi in Hindi over the telephone, Roy stated: “They (TMC) are targeting me because I belong to the family of Maharaja Krishnachandra. They are saying he sided with the British. They are calling us traitors. But they are not saying how much he worked for the welfare of the people. I am saying had he not done that, our Sanatan Dharma would have been destroyed.”

“Siraj-ud-Daulah was corrupt and a tormentor. Maharaj Krishnachandra did not do anything alone. A lot of kings got together. Many people, such as Jagat Seth (a merchant and money lender) worked hard and made it successful. Had it not happened, we would not be living as Hindus today. Our language and attire would be different. We would be living under the rule of some other people,” Roy advised Modi.

Although Roy was not express, it was obvious that by “it” and “that” she meant Siraj-ud-Daulah’s defeat during which Krishnachandra Roy performed a job in keeping with historic analysis that TMC is now utilizing in its counter-campaign and mocking the BJP candidate by calling her Mir Jafar.

Krishnachandra Roy, in keeping with researchers, was a propagator of orthodox Hindu non secular practices.

Replying to the BJP candidate, Modi stated: “Amrita Ji, in our childhood we read a lot about Krishnachandra Roy and his development model for Bengal. These people (TMC) are into vote bank politics. They will make a lot of baseless allegations and try to malign others by referring to incidents that happened 300 years ago. They do this to hide their crimes. When it comes to Bhagwan Ram, they ask for proof. This is a sign of their double standard. Don’t pay attention. Saving Bengal’s heritage is the challenge before you.”

The audio was circulated by the BJP’s nationwide media cell together with audio recordsdata of the Prime Minister’s dialog with 5 different candidates from throughout India, and BJP leaders in Bengal are making use of this audio file of their campaigns within the state. The file was additionally made accessible on the social gathering’s official WhatsApp group.

The audio has not been independently verified by HT.

In Nadia district, which is situated alongside the Bangladesh border, Hindus comprise 72.15% of the inhabitants, which is among the many highest in Bengal. There are 17 meeting segments of which 14 comprise two Lok Sabha constituencies, Krishnanagar and Ranaghat.

BJP received the Ranaghat seat in 2019, one of many 18 of Bengal’s 42 seats it received that 12 months.

Of the three remaining meeting segments in Nadia, one is a part of the Murshidabad Lok Sabha seat in adjoining Murshidabad district (which has Bengal’s highest Muslim inhabitants of 66.28%) that TMC received in 2019 whereas two falls beneath North 24 Parganas district’s Bongaon seat that BJP wrested.

What documented historical past says

The East India Company’s military was headed by Lord Clive who was described by British historian Percival Spear (1901-1982) within the e book A History of India as a “kingmaker and plunderer.”

“Clive then became aware of the plots to dethrone Siraja (as Spear spelt the name). He was moved by ambition, cupidity. Forty million sterling was said to lie in the treasury of Murshidabad,” Spear wrote.

“Overnight he (Clive) found himself, as he thought, the de Bussy of wealthy Bengal and Bihar who could dispose of their riches to the company and his followers.”

Murshidabad was the capital of the Bengal Province (masking Bengal, Bihar and Odisha) when the Nawabs dominated. The British later shifted the capital to Calcutta (now known as Kolkata) which remained the capital of British India from 1772 to 1911 earlier than Delhi gained the standing.

Ratnabali Chatterjee, a veteran professor of Islamic historical past, stated some historians from India and overseas reached conflicting conclusions on the conspiracy that labored towards Siraj-ud-Daula however none ever doubted his patriotism.

Chatterjee stated: “Clive anticipated that some people were ready to betray Siraj-ud-Daulah and Britain supported his plans. He was the one who started draining wealth from India to England. As years passed, Siraj-ud-Daulah was recognised as a national hero. Mir Madan and Mohanlal, his trusted aides, were Hindus. Yes, there was gossip about Siraj forcefully marrying a Hindu woman but that was never substantiated.”

Shouvik Mukhopadhyay, a historical past professor at Calcutta University, stated: “From the works of historians who researched on Siraj-ud-Daulah, it seems some people in the 18th century described him as a whimsical person and oppressor of both Hindus and Muslims. But this narrative seems to have been created by people who were eager to please the British for gains. It was a propaganda with no documentary evidence. The assessment of 19th-century historians and novelists, many of whom were Bengali Hindus, is completely different. They depicted him almost as a freedom fighter.”

Political science professor Udayan Bandopadhyay stated: “It is a fact that many kings and nawabs had ostentatious lifestyles but nobody can doubt that Siraj-ud-Daulah died fighting colonial aggression and people like Mir Jafar, Umichand (a Punjabi merchant), Jagat Seth and Krishnachandra Roy helped the British establish their empire in India. Even Joseph Stalin oppressed people in Russia but he eventually stood against Germany in WW2.”

“Those who are glorifying people like Krishnachandra in independent India are insulting 200 years of struggle for freedom,” Bandopadhyay added.


Content Source: www.hindustantimes.com


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here